Magazine as Metaphor
The life of a magazine art director assumes many sources of inspiration.
Typography is ubiquitous in signs, billboards and graffiti. Design
can be seen in the shapes of buildings, in sound, music, film,
television and, of course, in print. All contribute to an endless store
of visual wealth.
Among the “finds” have always been foreign magazines.
Luxuriously printed, lush with endless spreads, frequent nudity,
eloquent typography and mostly free of advertising [foreign magazines
make their money from newsstand sales as opposed to American magazines,
which make their money from advertising], foreign magazines have always
been a source for alternative concepts to magazine design.
The fact is, magazines are but metaphors for the various
cultures they represent. Japanese magazines are artfully packed with
information with barely a hint of white space. There is energy, a pace
to be found, in Japanese magazines, that speaks to and about its youth
culture. The Old World, with a culture much more vast and experienced
than America, is comfortable with space, while taking its time to tell
a story. The light is different in Europe. The photography is
different. The sensibility is simply different.
Modern design began in Europe. The Dada period (1916-23) in
particular created radical new forms of design. Type suddenly left the
constraints of the parallel; words and images were combined and
deconstructed in new industrial and technical ways that created forms
that would later be borrowed heavily in magazine design.
It is no surprise that in the richest periods of Harper’s Bazaar
and Vogue, Russian immigrants Alexey Brodovitch (Harper’s Bazaar,
1938–1958) and Alex Liberman (Conde Nast editorial director, 1962–1996)
With careers that spanned decades, both Brodovitch and Liberman
began as art directors and changed the way in which American fashion
was photographed and designed. What both brought to their publications
was a European sensibility, not only in the use of text and white space
but also in the use of European photographers such as Munkacsi, Man Ray
and George Hoyningen-Huene. Later, photographers Richard Avedon and
Irving Penn would make their unique identities known to American
magazines, though their photographs were clearly born from an acquired
Today, newsstands are rife with both American and European
magazines. European magazines tend to be larger, printed on better
paper and certainly more expensive. Foreign magazines cost $30 and
upward for a single issue. But they have remained for art directors a
sanctuary for the visual. Not as advertising-driven, European magazines
take chances. Nudity is simply a fact of life (although a recent ad for
Equinox Fitness Clubs featuring a bare-bottomed model albeit in a very
European monastic setting managed to finds it way into American
publications). The styling, the typography and the imagery tend be more
adventurous than the American counterpart.
Fairchild’s group design director, Edward Leida, was influenced
early on by the Italian architecture and design magazine Domus. “I feel
that my life as well as my work has been inspired by European
magazines. It’s hard to put my finger on one thing or nuance that I
have found inspirational, but there has always been a “cool” element,
and I mean cool as in cold and austere in the way they approach their
layout and imagery.”
Magazines are ultimately metaphors for the culture they
represent. Magazines incorporate and reflect the mindset of both
editors and art directors. American magazines are quick glances at
various niche markets, punctuated with niche market advertising,
adhering to the 40/60 editorial/advertising equation. Foreign
magazines, on the other hand, tend to reflect their countries as a
consolidated idea. For example, IssueOne from England, a hefty 9×12,
four pound fashion glossy that costs $20, has a gatefold cover, on both
the front and back covers. The three panel gatefold inside, both front
and back consists of bubbles, a three panel image of bubbles. No logos,
no copy, nothing but bubbles. It’s hard to imagine any American
publication giving bubbles six pages.
Randy Dunbar is an art and design specialist whose clients include Los Angeles magazine, Out and Muscle & Fitness. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.