Face Up: Hour Detroit
Issue: January 2013, The Auto Issue
Publishing Company: Hour Media
Art Director: Cassidy Zobl
Editor: Steve Wilke
In the Motor City, the North American International Auto Show (NAIMS), also known as the Detroit Auto Show, is much more than just a car expo. Being one of the city‚Äôs local magazine, Hour Detroit recognizes that the title must capture the essence of the auto show while also cutting through the storm of coverage surrounding the event.
‚ÄúThe auto show is a really big event in Detroit so I wanted to take the event side of it as opposed to the cars,‚ÄĚ says Cassidy Zobl, art director for Hour Detroit. ‚ÄúEveryone knows there are cars, and everyone loves the cars here, but there are events for weeks surrounding the auto show. I wanted to make it seem more fun and inviting. And, if you don‚Äôt necessarily like cars, something like this will still grab your eye because it‚Äôs so loud.‚ÄĚ
The showgirls on the cover, which are actually members of the Detroit Piston‚Äôs Dance Team, are a nod to the 1950s and help capture the spectacle that is the auto show.
Zobl hired an illustrator to create the Vegas-style Hour name, but said she ran into some trouble.
‚ÄúWhen the whole sign was on the cover, the Hour name was tiny,‚ÄĚ she says. ‚ÄúThe photographer, he is a Photoshop genius, ended up taking, piece by piece, the CGI sign and reconstructing it so that it would fit in with the space. The first couple times we tried, the girls were much smaller and it didn‚Äôt look right because the sign was so big. Getting that to fit in took about a week of tweaking, just for the sign.‚ÄĚ
‚ÄúThe yesteryear, Vegas-style, fashion metaphor embodies the attractive, innovative, stylish Hour cover strategy quite well. It‚Äôs fun and interesting, and a welcome departure from the typical auto issue cover, but overall I find it lacking ‚Äėvisual inspiration.‚Äô
‚ÄúThe cover image is well thought-out and executed as a complete piece‚ÄĒincluding the masthead components neatly integrated into the art (not easy to pull off!). But I am distracted by continuity and the execution struggles between photography and illustration, type and colors.
‚ÄúCover cut lines set in a white field is often a result of poor cover space and background planning, but here it compliments the headline-on-white-cards typographical approach.
‚ÄúIn general, the cover is a delightful, warm, and an innovative concept, which would have benefited from greater attention to composition and execution details.‚ÄĚ
Gene Fedele, VP, Corporate Creative Director, UBM
‚ÄúAs a city magazine, you don‚Äôt want the cover of your Auto Issue to be confused for a car enthusiast title. Hour Detroit avoids this in a playful way by leaving out the Corvettes, and focusing on the kitschy spectacle.
‚ÄúThey pull off the period look very nicely through lighting, costuming, hair, makeup and garishly oversaturated colors. The vintage show card concept they‚Äôre going for allows for the illustrated marquee that they‚Äôve added in post, but they would‚Äôve earned big points if that sign and those lights were practical. (And they would‚Äôve blown their budget in a big way as a result, I‚Äôm sure.)
‚ÄúTheir commitment to the concept extends to their treatment of secondary cover lines‚ÄĒwhich really recede as a result.
‚ÄúPersonal preference aside, I think this is a really fun and optimistic cover, and I‚Äôm glad they went with this approach.‚ÄĚ
Ben Purvis, Design Director, Runner‚Äôs World‚ÄĒRodale Inc.
Have a unique ‚Äúcover‚ÄĚ story? Contact associate editor T.J. Raphael at firstname.lastname@example.org.