ADVERTISEMENT



Hachette Dropping Out of the MPA Just Tip of the Iceberg

Tough times for magazine associations.


Tony Silber By Tony Silber
02/12/2009 -10:49 AM






I’m predicting that Hachette Filipacchi Media dropping its membership in the Magazine Publishers of America ("Hachette Drops Out of MPA") is just the tip of the iceberg. Publishers are feeling economic pain and, consequently, the associations, audit bureaus and others are as well. If this recession is long and as challenging as it is right now, there will be more high-profile dropouts.

Think of it from a publishing company’s perspective: Your revenue is declining, you’re laying people off, you’re freezing salaries, you’re not filling positions, you’re reducing frequencies, trim sizes, circulations, paper stock and more.

And as you comb through your budget trying to make the least damaging and least painful decisions, you see a line for association membership that may be $10,000 or may be $50,000. And in the case of the large companies, it’s certainly over $100,000.

There’s no way—no way—when you see that line that you don’t ask what the value is that you’re getting. Yes, you get lobbying for postal reform. Yes, you get research proving the value of magazine advertising. Yes, you get events with quality programs and valuable networking.

But in a time when all you want is to drive revenue with as lean a business as possible, those benefits are less compelling. Especially when you have to pay for virtually everything the association provides in addition to your dues. And that big, fat budget line becomes an easy target.

What publishers are looking for is not participation in committees and abstract reports and golf tournaments. Those are fine most of the time, but not now. Publishers want tools and resources that will keep them focused on effectively driving revenue in their markets.

It’s hard to overstate the message of HFM dropping out of MPA. Jack Kliger [pictured] was perhaps the highest profile and most effective chairman of the association in a decade or more. For his company to drop out within six months of Kliger stepping down as CEO says volumes about the extraordinary climate.

[EDITOR'S NOTE: Red 7 Media, FOLIO:'s parent company, is a member of the MPA.]

RELATED LINKS





Tony Silber By Tony Silber --

Post Comment / Discuss This Blog - Info/Rules

good post, well-argued
Submitted by Brian O'Leary on Thu, 02/12/2009 - 11:51.

Our (small) consultancy is also a member of MPA. Annual dues are $2,500 and pretty much serve as ante: you are eligible to attend MPA events at an additional charge. We renewed our membership for 2009, but it wasn't an automatic decision. While membership shows a commitment to the industry, we're wondering how many clients, current and potential, pay attention to it. Also, the MPA's decision to proceed with a lavish awards ceremony while many firms are retrenching (including those of at least one honoree) seemed more than a little out of touch. The MPA does offer value, as you point out. At the margin, though, you have to ask if paying dues is still a smart business decision.
you're right...unfortunately, more will follow Hachette
Submitted by Joseph Guerriero on Thu, 02/12/2009 - 12:23.

driving revenue while trying to re-invent a business model is a difficult thing to do, it's like changing the tires on a moving truck. unfortunately any expenditure that does not show a demonstrable return on investment will be subject to much scrutiny going forward. publishers need to be narrowly focused on revenue and re-invention nothing more, nothing less...
Hard times require hard decisions...
Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 02/12/2009 - 13:57.

The MPA must retrench and we all must decide in a slow growing industry how much we can afford for annual dinners and golfing outings. I suggest this money is better spent inside the company on our own clients. I am restricting Account Rep's T&E while our management is feting each other at annual dinners.
Times are certainly tough
Submitted by Stephanie Inglis on Tue, 02/17/2009 - 14:41.

Times are certainly tough and choices have to be made regarding what can be cut. I can say, though, that as someone who makes media buying decisions, I would far rather see publishers drop out of associations than make cuts in other areas. For example, I hope that publishers will not lower editorial standards or succumb to the false economy of dropping their media audit. I need that circulation report to make an informed decision (see www.BuySafeMedia.com if you don't know why). No circulation report, no advertising. Likewise, if the editorial is not there, people stop opening the book, which doesn't do my ads much good.

RECENTLY in Association and Non-Profit dots icon

MOST READ on FOLIOdots icon

FOLIO: Alerts & Newslettersdots icon

Sign up for our news alerts, special offers & feature updates:



FOLIO: Alerts
Breaking news & industry updates

FOLIO: Publishing Technology
The Latest on Trends, Issues & Products (2x Monthly)

FOLIO: Special Promos
Special offers & announcements from Partners, Sponsors & Red 7 Media

FOLIO: Update
Webinar, content & service feature updates



CAREER CENTER dots icon

Latest Featured Jobs


Join mediaPRO Today: Click Here


Media Pros Connect on the new professional and social network for the Magazine, eMedia & Publishing Industry today.