ADVERTISEMENT



Did Another Magazine ‘Lighten’ a Dark Woman?

Complex’s retouching of Kardashian follows trend.


Vanessa Voltolina By Vanessa Voltolina
03/31/2009 -09:00 AM






What do Beyonce, Michelle Obama, and Kim Kardashian have in common? They’ve all gone under a magazine’s Photoshop knife and come out looking lighter.

Most recently, Complex mistakenly released a pre-retouched image of socialite-model-actress Kim Kardashian on its Web site with (gasp!) cellulite on her thighs. The photo was only up for a few hours, and quickly taken down when the mistake was realized.

The cellulite, however, was less disturbing than the fact that the photo’s background—and Kardashian—got visibly lighter from pre-touch to retouch.

In 2005, Radar claimed that Vanity Fair lightened singer Beyonce’s skin color for its cover. And in the past few weeks, Michelle Obama’s airbrushed makeover on New York’s cover received its share of criticism. (Not as much as her husband’s Rolling Stone cover, which some alleged made the then-president-to-be look “whiter” and downright angelic.)

While some, like Fox News’ Megyn Kelly, believe that “any respectable magazine should be doing a little retouching,” how far is too far?

 

RELATED LINKS





Vanessa Voltolina By Vanessa Voltolina --

Post Comment / Discuss This Blog - Info/Rules

If the background and
Submitted by Eliz. on Tue, 03/31/2009 - 15:29.

If the background and subject were lightened together, then isn't it possible that the photo editor lightened everything in anticipation of too-dark printing or computer monitors? The same image can have multiple brightnesses depending on your monitor or printer.
Giving girls everywhere a complex
Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 04/01/2009 - 16:00.

So, we lightened her color so she would be prettier and we obviously subtracted about 10lbs to make her prettier... And we wonder why teenage girls in the US have eating disorders and huge complexes about their looks. It's about time for magazines to take some social responsibility for the things they print.
dark woman?
Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 04/01/2009 - 16:03.

Not sure I'd categorize Kim as "dark", Naomi Campbell is "dark", Jennifer Hudson is "dark". Kim K? not at all. That being said they did the obvious altering of cellulite and it does look like as a whole the entire image was lightened.
photo retouching
Submitted by Barry on Tue, 08/11/2009 - 09:27.

Actually, if both the background and subject were lightened, then it's likely they were simply correcting for the tone of the paper. It's not uncommon for photo editors to blow out a photo a little to compensate for not-quite-white paper. The unretouched image would have been used just for digital publication, in which case no lightening is needed.
Every woman wants to look her best
Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 08/11/2009 - 13:30.

As a photographer and retoucher I'm always asked to make women look slimmer, take out blemishes, and the biggest request to make them look younger by taking out wrinkles. P.s. the image looks color corrected, not lightened.

RECENTLY in Design and Production dots icon

MOST READ on FOLIOdots icon

FOLIO: Alerts & Newslettersdots icon

Sign up for our news alerts, special offers & feature updates:



FOLIO: Alerts
Breaking news & industry updates

FOLIO: Publishing Technology
The Latest on Trends, Issues & Products (2x Monthly)

FOLIO: Special Promos
Special offers & announcements from Partners, Sponsors & Red 7 Media

FOLIO: Update
Webinar, content & service feature updates



CAREER CENTER dots icon

Latest Featured Jobs